Bookmark
Whip up a taste of New Orleans right at home with this bright, punchy olive salad and big layers of meats and cheese. The pickled veggie mix steals the spotlight, giving every bite tons of flavor and a festive kick. Perfect for a picnic table or game night, this stacked sandwich always disappears fast at my place—people go back for more every time.
The first time I tried making this was during a Mardi Gras marathon and it stuck as a constant at family lunches. That garlicky olive scent reminds me of hanging out on hot summer porches.
Savory Ingredients
- Potato chips: perfect for snacking on the side, I love kettle-cooked ones like Zapps for extra crunch
- Pickled pepperoncini: adds a peppery zing right at the end, optional but totally worth it
- Capicola coppa or prosciutto: an awesome salty finish, pay a little more for the good stuff
- Mortadella or deli ham: brings a silky, rich texture, cut fresh at the counter for best results
- Provolone cheese: packs a bit of bold, nutty flavor, go for thin, even slices
- Genoa salami or pepperoni: spicy and punchy, always get it sliced as thin as possible
- Mozzarella cheese: makes things creamy, low moisture works best for clean layers
- Round Italian bread loaf with sesame seeds: keeps things classic and holds the fillings without falling apart
- Celery salt: adds savory depth, quickly check if yours smells fresh
- Freshly ground black pepper: for a spicy edge, grind it right before you use it
- Capers: bright, tangy, and little pops of flavor, get nonpareil if you can
- Red wine vinegar: cuts through all the meat and cheese richness, bold ones work best
- Extra-virgin olive oil: ties all the salad together, grab the goldest, most flavorful bottle
- Garlic clove: brings out a strong kick, always pick plump bulbs without marks
- Marinated roasted red peppers: gives sweetness and color, those packed in oil have great taste
- Giardiniera: supplies a crunchy bite, chunkier veggies stay crisp
- Pitted black olives: adds an earthy note, lightly brined are the way to go
- Pimento-stuffed olives: mild, a little tangy, and bright, look for firm ones if possible
Fantastic Step List
- Slice and Dish Up:
- After unwrapping, place your sandwich on a chopping board and cut into wedges. Serve right away with crunchy chips or pepperoncini on the side.
- Warm It Up For a Crunch:
- If you like it toasted, crank the oven up to three seventy five F, put your wrapped sandwich in, and warm for about ten to twenty minutes. The bread should be crusty but not too hard.
- Squeeze and Rest the Stack:
- Tightly wrap the whole thing in foil, set something heavy like a Dutch oven or stacked books on top, and let it all rest at room temp at least an hour or up to three. This helps every layer mingle and the sandwich settle down.
- Top it Off and Press:
- Spoon the rest of your olive salad over everything, and pour a little reserved oil on the bread top. Cap it off with the top half of your loaf and gently press it down.
- Time for Filling Layers:
- Use half your mozzarella, then all the mortadella, work in sliced salami, another layer of provolone, more mozzarella, capicola or prosciutto, and finally the rest of the provolone. Always start with olive salad on the bread to soak in the flavors.
- Bread Prep:
- Cut your loaf in half with a sharp knife. If it's super fluffy inside, dig out some of the bread, leaving about an inch and a half shell. That way the fillings fit without things getting soggy.
- Make That Olive Salad:
- Finely chop garlic, pimento olives, black olives, giardiniera, and roasted peppers, tossing each into a bowl. Stir in olive oil, red wine vinegar, pepper, celery salt, plus capers. Mix well, cover, and let it chill for at least one hour (up to a week). The longer you leave it, the tastier it gets.
Bookmark
Honestly, the olive salad does it for me every time—I keep nibbling while putting sandwiches together. My kids link these big sandwiches with those chill road trips or lazy parade days. The smiles are huge when this monster gets sliced up for the table.
Keeping Leftovers Fresh
Stick any extras in foil and stash them in your fridge—they’ll keep for two days, easy. When you want it warm again, just pop the whole thing (still in the foil) in a three seventy five degree oven for fifteen minutes or so till the filling’s hot and the bread’s got bite. Slice when you’re ready to eat, so nothing turns into mush.
Swap Choices
No round Italian loaf? Grab a French loaf or ciabatta in a pinch, though the bite will be different. For a veggie option, try roasted eggplant and zucchini with extra cheese standing in for deli meat. Use any briny green olive you like if you want more tartness instead of pimento-stuffed ones.
How to Serve
This big boy works great as lunch on its own, but I like it with tangy artichokes, crisp cucumber salad, or something pickled on the side. For parties, slice smaller squares to make snack-size bites. If you’re outside, wrap up in parchment and foil to keep it cool and fresh.
Bookmark
A Bit of Backstory
These piled-high sandwiches got their start with Sicilian immigrants bringing flavors from home to New Orleans. The sesame-studded loaf is a classic, and every shop makes their own special olive salad mix. Making one yourself is like cooking up a little piece of Louisiana culture in your own kitchen.
Frequently Asked Questions About Recipes
- → Which kind of bread is ideal for making muffuletta?
If you can grab a big Italian round loaf with sesame seeds, that's the classic choice, but you can swap in ciabatta or even French bread for sturdy, soak-up-the-flavor sandwiches.
- → Can I whip up the olive mix days before?
Definitely, prep the olive mix up to a week ahead and stash it in an airtight container in your fridge so the flavors get even better.
- → What's a good amount of time to press the sandwich after building it?
Wrap it up and set a heavy object on top, then let it chill at room temp for about 1 to 3 hours to blend all those flavors nicely.
- → Do I have to toast it before eating?
Toasting is your call, but if you heat the whole foil-wrapped sandwich in the oven, the bread crisps up and the cheese gets all melty—total win.
- → What other meats work if I don’t have everything listed?
Traditionally you'll find Genoa salami, mortadella, capicola, or prosciutto, but feel free to use ham or pepperoni—whatever you like or have on hand still makes it tasty.
- → Got leftovers? What’s the best way to keep them fresh?
Just wrap up any leftovers in foil, pop them in the fridge for up to two days, and when you're ready to eat, warm them in the oven (still wrapped) at 375º so the bread stays crisp.